Why renew if we can’t see the benefit?

Sam and the vendor lean over an open ledger together. “Renewal fee” and “Team time” appear under Costs. Sam’s pencil hovers over a blank line under Benefits while the vendor holds a report with one item checked in gold.

“Hey, you think I can get a two-week extension?”

Turns out a software renewal “landed” on my colleague’s plate two days before the current agreement expired. They needed more time to understand and build the case to send up the chain.

“Some do, especially if the renewal is important to them. What’s it do?”

The company had been using the tool for a couple of years. My colleague wasn’t part of the purchase and didn’t use it daily. To the best of their recollection, it fired off maybe once in the last two years. Pushing deeper, we weren’t sure whether another security tool they already use would have caught it anyway.

So I asked what benefit the company got from the tool.

They didn’t know.

Value = benefits − costs.

When it’s time for renewal, the price is clear. That’s the amount going on the purchase order. Costs include what it takes to run the tool. How much time, how much energy, across how many people? Hard to see when it’s not in your daily purview.

I asked if they’d heard from the vendor.

“Not yet.”

So I asked, “If the vendor can’t show the benefit, why is it on you to?”

Astute vendors see how their solution works across multiple clients. What do they see that we don’t yet?

That helps us answer “What did the tool allow us to do that we couldn’t do otherwise?” Once we can see the benefit, we can show it to the person making the renewal decision, weighed against the full cost.

My colleague needed more time to make the case for renewal. Maybe what they’d have to show at the end of those two weeks was a good reason to let it go.

← All Insights